International Seminar on Selective Inference
A weekly online seminar on selective inference, multiple testing, and post-selection inference.
Gratefully inspired by the Online Causal Inference Seminar
A weekly online seminar on selective inference, multiple testing, and post-selection inference.
Gratefully inspired by the Online Causal Inference Seminar
For announcements and Zoom invitations please subscribe to our mailing list. Our seminar (typically) runs on Mondays, at 8:30am PT / 11:30am ET / 4:30pm London / 5:30pm Amsterdam / 6:30pm Tel Aviv.
Monday, November 16, 2026 [link]
Speaker: Dan Kluger (MIT)
Title: M-estimation under Two-Phase Multiwave Sampling with Applications to Prediction-Powered Inference
Abstract: In two-phase multiwave sampling, inexpensive measurements are collected on a large sample and expensive, more informative measurements are adaptively obtained on subsets of units across multiple waves. Adaptively collecting the expensive measurements can increase efficiency but complicates statistical inference. We give valid estimators and confidence intervals for M-estimation under adaptive two-phase multiwave sampling. We focus on the case where proxies for the expensive variables -- such as predictions from pretrained machine learning models -- are available for all units and propose a Multiwave Predict-Then-Debias estimator that combines proxy information with the expensive, higher-quality measurements to improve efficiency while removing bias. We establish asymptotic linearity and normality and propose asymptotically valid confidence intervals. We also develop an approximately greedy sampling strategy that improves efficiency relative to uniform sampling. Data-based simulation studies support the theoretical results and demonstrate efficiency gains.
Discussant: Alessandro Sinai (Stanford University)
Links: [Relevant papers: paper #1]
Monday, November 30, 2026 [link]
Speaker: Souhardya Sengupta (Harvard University)
Title: Co-sufficient weighting: leveraging sparsity for more powerful variable selection in the linear model
Abstract: We show that for the problem of controlled variable selection in the Gaussian linear model, informative and p-value-independent weights (for weighted multiple testing) can be derived entirely from sufficient statistics and a belief in sparsity using only the data itself and no external quantitative side information. Using these weights, which we call \emph{co-sufficient weights} (CSW), in weighted versions of Holm's procedure and the Benjamini--Hochberg (BH) procedure results in substantially higher power than their unweighted analogues when the true coefficient vector is sparse, while retaining Holm's exact validity and BH's highly robust empirical validity regardless of sparsity. We demonstrate the superior performance of our proposed weighted methods compared to their unweighted analogues and other competing methods in a wide range of simulations and an application to HIV drug resistance.
Discussant:
Links: [Relevant papers: paper #1]
Monday, December 7, 2026 [link]
Speaker: Lei Shi (Adobe)
Title: Asymptotic theory of the quadratic assignment procedure for dyadic data analysis
Abstract: The quadratic assignment procedure (QAP) is a popular tool for analyzing dyadic data in medical and social sciences. To test the association between two dyadic measurements represented by two symmetric matrices, QAP calculates the p-value by permuting the units, or equivalently, by permuting the rows and columns of one matrix in the same way. Its extension to the regression setting, known as the multiple regression QAP, has also gained popularity, especially in psychometrics. However, the statistics theory for QAP has not been fully established in the literature. We fill the gap in this paper. We formulate the network models underlying various QAPs. We derive (a) the asymptotic sampling distributions of some canonical test statistics and (b) the corresponding asymptotic permutation distributions induced by QAP under strong and weak null hypotheses. Task (a) relies on applying the theory of U-statistics, and task (b) relies on applying the theory of double-indexed permutation statistics. The combination of tasks (a) and (b) provides a relatively complete picture of QAP. Overall, our asymptotic theory suggests that using properly studentized statistics in QAP is a robust choice in that it is finite-sample exact under the strong null hypothesis and preserves the asymptotic type one error rate under the weak null hypothesis.
Discussant:
Links: [Relevant papers: paper #1]
The seminars are held on Zoom and last 60 minutes:
45 minutes of presentation
15 minutes of discussion, led by an invited discussant
Moderators collect questions using the Q&A feature during the seminar.
You can attend by clicking the link to join (there is no need to register in advance).
More instructions for attendees can be found here.
Jelle Goeman (Leiden University)
Nikos Ignatiadis (University of Chicago)
Lihua Lei (Stanford University)
Zhimei Ren (University of Pennsylvania)
Will Fithian (UC Berkeley)
Rina Barber (University of Chicago)
Daniel Yekutieli (Tel Aviv University)
If you have feedback or suggestions or want to propose a speaker, please e-mail us at selectiveinferenceseminar@gmail.com.
Broadly construed, selective inference means searching for interesting patterns in data, usually with inferential guarantees that account for the search process. It encompasses:
Multiple testing: testing many hypotheses at once (and paying disproportionate attention to rejections)
Post-selection inference: examining the data to decide what question to ask, or what model to use, then carrying out one or more appropriate inferences
Adaptive / interactive inference: sequentially asking one question after another of the same data set, where each question is informed by the answers to preceding questions
Cheating: cherry-picking, double dipping, data snooping, data dredging, p-hacking, HARKing, and other low-down dirty rotten tricks; basically any of the above, but done wrong!